The Neoliberal Arts Versus When Public Goes Private

242 views 4 pages ~ 909 words
Get a Custom Essay Writer Just For You!

Experts in this subject field are ready to write an original essay following your instructions to the dot!

Hire a Writer

Over the years, modern challenges, along with a revolution in the dynamics of problems in communities around the world, have seen major changes made to many of the curriculum programs to align with the different adaptations that need to take place. In particular, the US has been dealing with questions of importance to the old school system and the manner in which education issues have been dealt with at different stages. Apparently, no universal solution can come to address all the root problems. Many experts in the field of education appear to give diverse perspectives about the path ahead when it comes to learning at various stages. Political and business interest groups have also entered the debate with each side seeking to front its argument in the hope benefitting from the implementation of policies that take their interests into consideration. This paper looks at the articles The Neoliberal Arts Versus When Public Goes Privateby William Deresiewicz and Diane Ravitch respectively that delve into the issue education provision exploring some of the developments in the provision of education in the USA, and compares the two texts.

Some similarities are also clear from the two articles. Both articles explore the problems in the education sector that impact on their outcome. A focus on the marketability of the courses is seen as a factor that greatly influences the direction of university courses, a desire to improve the performance of students at public schools is the argument at the center of the initiatives to privatize them. The text by William captures the views of some pundits and finds the fault in their arguments and then disputes the views that it sees as not being in line with the desires of a good education system. Daine Ravitch also applies a similar approach in her work. She explores the views of the two opposing schools of thought but then settles for the one she feels presents a more competent argument that is in line with her thoughts on the subject matter. In addition, the position of the two authors on education borders on the betterment of educational outcomes. Both William and Diane are keen finding solutions to the mess in the education sector by offering alternatives that they believe will result in genuinely positive outcomes for the affected students.

There are several differences between the two articles. Even though both address issues bedeviling the delivery of education in the US, the first article, "The Neoliberal Arts" focus on the education at the tertiary level exploring the ills problems with college education while the second one, "When Public Goes Private" looks at issues at the primary level. Second is that the first author has taken issue with apparent changes in the content aim of education while the second author raises concerns on the trend catching up intent on seeing increased privatization of public schools under the pretense of bettering them and improving their performance with their real motive being making huge profits. William uses summaries on the sides of each section of his text that offer an insight into what the sections are all about giving the reader an easy time when scheming through looking for specific information. The strategy is commendable at it encourages those who may not in the mood to go through the whole to text to at least check out some of the sections that are of greatest to them. Diane's article fails to offer readers such an opportunity, a situation that may result in less interest among poor readers who may find going through the text tiresome.

Other variations in the two texts are in relation to the way the authors present their work. William in his article has shown great organization. He presents his work in a way that is attractive to the reader often positioning different sections differently while also ensuring that each paragraph looks different from the other. With such kind of presentation, it can appeal to the young readers most of whom tend to perceive attractive presentation of work as being representative of captivating content. Diane, on the other hand, is more interested in her writing than the appearance. She uses fewer images compared to William while also having almost identical paragraphs in terms of appearance.

Clearly, the two texts The Neoliberal Arts Versus When Public Goes Private by William Deresiewicz and Diane Ravitch respectively address issues related to education but at different levels with some variations in the way they present their work. The texts explore the ills that lead to inefficiency in the education sector. Both authors acknowledge the views of proponents of the different approaches to education but then settle on their positions that make them appear decisive. However, there are also differences in the two authors texts. While William's focus is on college education and its quality, Diane's focus is on the primary education exploring the issue of privatization of public schools. There are also differences in the pictorial presentation of the work that may affect the reader's interest in the each of the texts.

Works Cited

Ravitch, Diane. "When Public Goes Private, As Trump Wants: What Happens?". The New York Review of Books, 2016,

Deresiewicz, William. "[Essay] | The Neoliberal Arts, By William Deresiewicz | Harper's Magazine". Harper's magazine. N.p., 2015. Web. 13 Mar. 2017. [Accessed 13 Mar. 2017].

October 12, 2022

Hero Learning

Number of pages


Number of words




Writer #



Expertise Education System
Verified writer

Nixxy is accurate and fun to cooperate with. I have never tried online services before, but Nixxy is worth it alone because she helps you to feel confident as you share your task and ask for help. Amazing service!

Hire Writer

This sample could have been used by your fellow student... Get your own unique essay on any topic and submit it by the deadline.

Eliminate the stress of Research and Writing!

Hire one of our experts to create a completely original paper even in 3 hours!

Hire a Pro

Similar Categories